# The Lord of the Rings — map and place research

Verified 21 October 2026. Scope: the West of Middle-earth at the end of the Third Age, as drawn on the general map. Place notes stay spoiler-light: they describe places, not what happens there.

## Published artwork

- **Template (book map).** *The West of Middle-earth at the End of the Third Age*, Christopher Tolkien's 1980 redrawing of the 1953–54 general map, from [Curtis Wright Maps, Maps of Middle-earth](https://curtiswrightmaps.com/product/maps-of-middle-earth-3/) ([scan](https://curtiswrightmaps.com/wp-content/uploads/map_15.47x19.05_01-23-26_inv008125c.jpg)): the sheet issued with the 1995 Quality Paperback Book Club edition (by arrangement with Houghton Mifflin); HarperCollins editions carry this version from 2005. `published-map.jpg` is that scan cropped to the drawing (scan pixels 180,200 – 5650,4450) and halved to 2735 × 2125. Its lines, lettering, frame and colours are unchanged. It appears at full zoom-out with its credit and fades into the 3D view.
- **Layer 1.** *Rohan, Gondor and Mordor*, Christopher Tolkien's 1955 large-scale map for *The Return of the King*, same issue ([scan](https://curtiswrightmaps.com/wp-content/uploads/map_17.52x18.00_01-23-26_inv008125c.jpg)). Registered onto the template (below). Thirteen places the general map omits come from it: the beacon hills (Halifirien, Calenhad, Min-Rimmon, Eilenach, Amon Dîn), the Drúadan Forest, Firien Wood, Linhir, Ethring, Calembel, Henneth Annûn, Cirith Ungol and Durthang.
- **Layer 2.** The original general map (drawn 1953 for the first edition; this scan is the 1978 Houghton Mifflin reprint of the second edition), from [Curtis Wright Maps, Maps of Middle-earth](https://curtiswrightmaps.com/product/maps-of-middle-earth-2/) ([scan](https://curtiswrightmaps.com/wp-content/uploads/map_15.91x18.47_09-25-25_inv007620c.jpg)). Registered onto the template as a cross-check of its placements. No position is taken from it. It also reaches further south (Umbar, Harad) than this world.

The reference scans and tracing proofs stay local in `tools/the-lord-of-the-rings/ref/` and are not committed. The tracing tools (`trace_coast.py`, `features.mjs`, `places.mjs`, `build-world.mjs`) regenerate `world.js`, `registration.json` and `research.json`.

## Registration

The plate is the world: one world unit is 1.140 plate pixels. The plate's scale bar gives 1.53 plate pixels per mile, so a world unit is about 0.75 miles. World bounds are [-1200, -932.4, 1200, 932.4]. The template's 52 point places are its own anchors; their measurement uncertainty is about 4 plate pixels.

**Layer 1: Rohan, Gondor and Mordor → template.** Least-squares affine fit over 11 shared places, then an inverse-distance correction so that every anchor lands exactly on the template. RMS residual before correction: **27.7 plate px (about 18 miles)** (Pelargir's plate anchor was corrected onto its printed mark on 23 Oct 2026). The two maps were never one projection (the general map was redrawn by hand), so the general map decides placement wherever it names a place. Only places it omits are taken from this sheet, and their placement is recorded as `partial`. The camp on Gorgoroth is nudged 14 plate px east, off the Morgai ridge onto the plateau where the sheet draws it.

| Anchor | Layer pixel | Plate pixel | Residual (plate px) |
|---|---|---|---|
| pelargir | 2600, 3418 | 1693, 1692 | 20.5, -3.8 |
| minas-tirith | 3175, 2265 | 1750, 1487 | -30.9, -14.7 |
| osgiliath | 3308, 2147 | 1776, 1478 | -28.9, -2.8 |
| minas-morgul | 3490, 2005 | 1815, 1480 | -22.6, 24.7 |
| cair-andros | 3195, 1763 | 1765, 1422 | -23, 1.7 |
| mount-doom | 4095, 1752 | 1962, 1418 | 17.3, 11.9 |
| barad-dur | 4372, 1758 | 2026, 1400 | 33.1, -3.2 |
| morannon | 3600, 1055 | 1840, 1295 | -23.5, -5.4 |
| isenmouthe | 3730, 1413 | 1925, 1345 | 41.4, -11.4 |
| edoras | 455, 840 | 1316, 1306 | -1.7, -3.1 |
| erech | 425, 1475 | 1326, 1418 | 18.1, 6 |

**Layer 2: original general map → template.** Least-squares affine over 12 shared places from the Grey Havens to Mount Doom (with inverse-distance correction for the three names taken from it: Michel Delving, Buckland and the Bay of Belfalas label). RMS residual: **23.4 plate px (about 15 miles)**. The largest disagreements (about 28 miles) are at the Grey Havens and Isengard. Bree, Weathertop, Rivendell, Tharbad and Hobbiton agree within about 5 miles. This confirms that the 1980 redrawing keeps the earlier map's placements within hand-drawing tolerance.

| Anchor | Layer pixel | Plate pixel | Residual (plate px) |
|---|---|---|---|
| grey-havens | 1372, 1386 | 403, 527 | 30.4, -30.9 |
| hobbiton | 1764, 1354 | 637, 552 | 7.5, 6.9 |
| bree | 2088, 1322 | 840, 561 | -1.9, 30 |
| weathertop | 2300, 1322 | 978, 535 | -2.6, -0.1 |
| fornost | 2046, 1110 | 803, 401 | -14.5, 4.8 |
| tharbad | 2266, 1774 | 946, 828 | -5.9, 7.9 |
| rivendell | 2796, 1300 | 1305, 528 | -0.4, -2.5 |
| isengard | 2592, 2262 | 1122, 1112 | -36.2, -22.8 |
| edoras | 2850, 2500 | 1316, 1306 | -7.5, 15.9 |
| erebor | 3620, 995 | 1846, 338 | -2.8, -15.4 |
| dol-guldur | 3248, 1790 | 1602, 862 | 7.9, 13.2 |
| mount-doom | 3790, 2685 | 1962, 1418 | 26.2, -6.9 |

## What was traced

- **Coast and water:** the main coastline, Himling, Tol Falas, the Ethir Anduin and the Bay of Belfalas come from a seeded flood-fill of the template's sea hatching, with hand barriers where channels leak. The Sea of Rhûn, Núrnen, Lake Evendim, the Long Lake and Nen Hithoel are held as lakes. The narrow head of the Gulf of Lhûn is carved by hand up to Mithlond, because it is thinner than one terrain cell.
- **Rivers, ranges, forests and roads:** 35 rivers in three widths. Every printed range (Misty Mountains, Ered Luin, Grey Mountains, White Mountains, Ephel Dúath, Ered Lithui, Mountains of Angmar and others) and named peak is traced. Mirkwood, Fangorn, Lothlórien, the Old Forest, the Chetwood and other woods are traced. So are the East Road, Greenway, Great West Road and the roads of Gondor and Mordor.
- **Places:** 229 records (inventory of 23 Oct 2026, read tile by tile from the full-resolution scan):
  - every legible name on the template: settlements, fortresses, ruins, fords, bridges, passes, regions, ranges, forests, marshes, rivers (including the Langwell, Greylin, Forest River, Hoarwell, Loudwater, Glanduin, Gladden River, Nimrodel, Limlight, Adorn, Snowbourn, Lefnui, the five rivers of Lebennin and the Mering Stream) and roads (East-West Road, Greenway, North-South Road, Old Forest Road, Harad Road), plus the Undeeps, the East Bight, Andrath, Midgewater, Dunland, Enedwaith and the Morgai;
  - from the Rohan, Gondor and Mordor sheet: Dunharrow and the Starkhorn, the Entwade, the Folde and the Fenmarch, the Mouths of Entwash, all seven beacon hills (Erelas and Nardol added), the Stonewain Valley, the Grey Wood, Mindolluin, the Crossings of Erui, Tarlang's Neck, the Great West Road and the camp on Gorgoroth;
  - from the original general map: Michel Delving (marked "on the White Downs"), Buckland and the label of the Bay of Belfalas;
  - named only in the text and placed by interpretation beside a mapped neighbour (`placement.status: interpretive`): Bywater, Staddle, Combe, Archet, the Prancing Pony, Caradhras, the Redhorn Gate, Mirrormere, Cerin Amroth, Caras Galadhon, Dale, the Argonath, Amon Hen, Amon Lhaw, Tol Brandir, Methedras, Harrowdale, Orthanc, Meduseld, the Hornburg and the Pelennor.
  - Nen Hithoel and Ithilien are drawn on the template without that exact label (an unnamed lake; N. and S. Ithilien), and say so.
- **Evidence:** `research.json` records 228 places as `supported` and one (the camp, a bare map label) as `partial`. Facts for 165 places come from the [Encyclopedia of Arda](https://www.encyclopedia-of-arda.com/) (one entry per place, linked in each record; claims paraphrase the entry's location summary), the rest from the Wikipedia articles on [Minas Tirith](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minas_Tirith), [Rivendell](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rivendell), [Bree](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bree_(Middle-earth)), [the Shire](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shire_(Middle-earth)), [Moria](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moria_(Middle-earth)), [Isengard](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isengard), [Rohan](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rohan_(Middle-earth)), [Lothlórien](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lothl%C3%B3rien), [Mirkwood](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirkwood), [Mordor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mordor), [Gondor](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gondor), [the Lonely Mountain](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lonely_Mountain), [Eriador](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eriador) and [the Grey Havens](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grey_Havens). Tolkien Gateway (HTTP 403) and its archive copies were unreachable, and fan wikis are not used.
- **Corrections in this pass:** Pelargir moved onto its printed mark (it sat on its label); the Ringló, Ciril, Gilrain, Serni, Celos, Sirith and Erui retraced from the plate (three were drawn in the wrong valleys).
- **Mountains:** `glyph_peaks.py` reads the plate's inked mountain glyphs (black ink, opened to drop lines, sampled every 13 px) and makes one summit per glyph, 620 in all, on top of the traced range envelopes, so the 3D ranges line up with the printed glyphs as the plate fades.

## Visual brief

A cartoony low-poly diorama on the shared living-atlas renderer. It is not a film or game look. Sizes are exaggerated so that landmarks read at map scale.

- **Land:** green Shire and Eriador, gold Rohan grass, golden mallorns in Lórien, with taller mallorns at Caras Galadhon. Mirkwood is dark. The Brown Lands and Dagorlad are bare, and Mordor and Gorgoroth are ash-grey. The Misty, White, Blue and Grey Mountains carry snow on their summits and crags on their steep sides; Mordor's ranges stay dark and snowless. Rauros throws up spray, and the Dead Marshes and Midgewater glimmer at night.
- **Gondor:** Minas Tirith has seven D-shaped white circles, each with its crenellated wall and terraces of houses, a dark outer wall with the Great Gate facing east, the rock prow, the Tower Hall and the White Tower, set against Mindolluin (the close scene is separate). The Rammas Echor is an open arc around the Pelennor. Osgiliath is ruined, with a broken bridge. Minas Morgul is a pale walled city with a tall tower and a bridge before its gate, Dol Amroth is white by the sea, and all seven beacons light at night.
- **Rohan:** Meduseld is a golden hall on Edoras's green hill, inside a palisade, framed from the north with the mountains behind. The Hornburg's tower and curtain wall stand on their rock with the Deeping Wall and Helm's Dike below; Dunharrow's hold sits up Harrowdale under the Starkhorn.
- **Isengard:** a black ring wall around a horned Orthanc that glows like fire inside at night.
- **Mordor:** Mount Doom has smoke and crater light. Barad-dûr is a black stepped tower with a red light at its summit by night. The Black Gate stands in the pass, between the Towers of the Teeth on their spurs. The Tower of Cirith Ungol rises in three tiers over its walled court.
- **North and east:** Rivendell has pale halls and towers. Hobbiton has round doors, domes and a mill, and the Party Tree stands nearby. Bree has an inn and a hedge, with Staddle, Combe and Archet nearby; Michel Delving, Bywater and Brandy Hall are hobbit-holes, and the High Hay fences Buckland. Weathertop is a tall hill with a ruined ring. The Brandywine Bridge and the Last Bridge are arched, Tharbad's bridge is broken and Sarn Ford has stepping stones. Moria's tall doors stand in the cliff with two holly trees; the Tower Hills carry three white towers. Erebor, Dale and Esgaroth on the Long Lake are here, along with the Woodland Realm's gate, Dol Guldur, the Argonath, the Tower Hills, and the ruins of Arnor.
- **Towns:** twelve towns use the shared settlement builder: Hobbiton, Bree, Edoras, Dol Amroth, Pelargir, Linhir, Ethring, Calembel, Dale, Esgaroth, the Grey Havens and Rivendell. Their architecture is original interpretation.

## Not shown

- The Westmarch (named on the original general map) was added to the Shire after the War of the Ring, so it stays out of an end-of-the-Third-Age map.
- Names beyond the template's frame on the original map (Umbar, Harad, Far Harad) are outside this world.
- Close scenes of the Shire and Minas Tirith are separate scenes with their own sources.
